The BCS is an evil plot to overthrow the world! It must be stopped at all costs!

I think the biggest problem with the BCS is that you're asking a computer to factor in too many variables. There is a simple question that only humans can answer over beer and pretzels: Which team kicks more ass?! Sure, you man never come to a concrete answer, but that debate is what makes sports great. Human polls are the only way to go unless the system is scrapped all together.